The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit recently resolved a high-profile trademark dispute involving MillerKnoll, Inc. and the estate of George Nelson, the renowned former design director of Herman Miller, Inc. (later renamed MillerKnoll). The case centered on the ownership and use of intellectual property rights associated with the iconic “Bubble Lamp,” a geometric hanging light fixture designed by Nelson.
The litigation arose after MillerKnoll asserted ownership of the Bubble Lamp intellectual property (IP), prompting Nelson’s heirs to file suit alleging trademark infringement, fraud, unjust enrichment, and related tort claims. The plaintiffs sought cancellation of MillerKnoll’s trademark registrations for the Bubble Lamp design.
The origins of the dispute trace back to Nelson’s mid-20th century employment at Herman Miller, where he had no formal written agreement regarding IP ownership or use of the Bubble Lamp design. Instead, Nelson operated under a verbal agreement entitling him to royalties on all designs he submitted. After Nelson’s departure, a 1957 written agreement established that Herman Miller would pay Nelson royalties for furniture products and patterns he designed.
Following Nelson’s death in 1986, his widow Jacqueline Nelson inherited any IP rights. In 2006, Jacqueline entered into a royalty agreement with Herman Miller, agreeing to a 1.5% royalty rate per unit sold for certain Nelson-designed furniture products. Although this agreement did not explicitly cover the Bubble Lamp IP, it allowed for the addition of products in the future.
In 2015, Mico Nelson, son of George and Jacqueline Nelson and acting under Jacqueline’s power of attorney, executed an addendum expanding the 2006 agreement to include “Nelson branded Lamp Products” and other Nelson-branded products not previously covered. This addendum effectively incorporated the Bubble Lamp IP into the licensed products.
The plaintiffs initiated suit in the Southern District of New York in 2021, asserting six claims: fraud; conspiracy to commit fraud; unjust enrichment; trademark infringement under the Lanham Act (15 U.S.C. § 1125(a)); common law trademark infringement and unfair competition; and cancellation of design registrations under 15 U.S.C. §§ 1119 and 1052(d). The case was later transferred to the Western District of Michigan.
After discovery, the district court granted summary judgment to MillerKnoll on all counts. The court found that MillerKnoll’s use of the Bubble Lamp IP was authorized under the 2006 agreement and the 2015 addendum, and that Mico Nelson ratified this use by accepting millions of dollars in royalty payments. The plaintiffs appealed.
The Sixth Circuit panel affirmed the district court’s ruling, agreeing that the agreements unambiguously authorized MillerKnoll to manufacture, sell, and own the Bubble Lamp IP. The court emphasized that the 2006 agreement defined “Licensed Products” as those owned by MillerKnoll, thereby defeating the plaintiffs’ federal and state infringement claims.
Additionally, the court found that Mico Nelson’s acceptance of royalty payments constituted ratification of MillerKnoll’s use and ownership of the Bubble Lamp IP, providing an independent basis for affirming summary judgment on infringement and tort claims.
Regarding the plaintiffs’ request to cancel MillerKnoll’s trademark registrations, the appeals court found no evidence of fraudulent statements made to the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office. Consequently, the court upheld MillerKnoll’s trademark rights.
This decision confirms MillerKnoll’s authorized ownership and use of the Bubble Lamp intellectual property, reinforcing the enforceability of licensing agreements and ratification through royalty acceptance in trademark disputes involving legacy design rights.
6th Circuit Upholds MillerKnoll’s Trademark Rights to George Nelson’s Iconic Bubble Lamp Design The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit has affirmed a lower court’s ruling granting summary judgment to MillerKnoll, Inc. in a trademark infringement dispute brought by the estate of famed designer George Nelso... Read the full IIPLA article: https://iipla.org/news/6th-circuit-upholds-millerknoll-s-trademark-rights-to-george-nelson-s-iconic-bubble-lamp-design