Congressman Jerrold Nadler, Ranking Member of the House Judiciary Subcommittee on the Administrative State, Regulatory Reform, and Antitrust, has voiced strong concerns over the unchecked use of copyrighted materials by artificial intelligence (AI) companies. In a detailed op-ed published by Billboard, Nadler emphasized the urgent need for congressional intervention to protect creators from intellectual property (IP) theft amid rapid technological advancements.
Earlier this month, Nadler, alongside Congressmen Jamie Raskin and Hank Johnson, filed an amicus brief opposing the Department of Justice’s (DOJ) position that supports AI companies training their models on copyrighted works without compensating rights holders. The brief was submitted in the Southern District of New York in the case In re OpenAI, Inc. Copyright Infringement Litigation. It argues that the DOJ’s stance conflicts with the explicit provisions of the Copyright Act, which contains no national security exception permitting private companies to freely use copyrighted content.
Reflecting on his three decades of service on the House Judiciary Committee, Nadler underscored his commitment to holding powerful corporations accountable for exploiting American creators. He warned that while AI technology is often heralded as “super intelligence,” it more accurately represents “stolen intelligence” due to its reliance on unauthorized use of creative works.
Currently, numerous lawsuits in the United States and internationally accuse AI developers of infringing copyrights by training their models on millions of articles, songs, books, voice recordings, videos, and other creative content without permission or payment. The outcomes of these cases are poised to have significant implications for the creative industries.
Nadler expressed particular concern over the DOJ’s recent brief filed in New York Times v. Microsoft and OpenAI, which supports Microsoft and OpenAI against allegations that they copied millions of New York Times articles to train ChatGPT. Court documents recently unsealed reveal that a senior Microsoft scientist privately described this practice as “an astonishing theft of unprecedented proportions.” Despite this, the DOJ under the Trump administration argued that such use constitutes “fair use,” dismissing clear evidence of market harm.
This DOJ argument, while presented in a single filing, risks becoming a precedent that AI developers might invoke to justify widespread intellectual property infringement.
The threat extends beyond journalism. Nadler highlighted the music industry’s struggles, citing the lawsuit against Suno, a leading AI music generator accused of training its model on major record labels’ recordings without authorization. Suno claims “fair use” despite admitting in court to using nearly all accessible music files of reasonable quality from the internet. Should the DOJ’s position prevail, companies like Suno would be incentivized to continue such practices.
The proliferation of AI-generated content is already causing tangible market harm. Streaming platforms are flooded with AI-created tracks, often indistinguishable to listeners, which dilutes revenue streams for human artists. Experts estimate that streaming fraud facilitated by AI costs artists and rights holders hundreds of millions, potentially billions, annually.
This dynamic disproportionately harms creators, from global superstars to independent musicians striving to build careers. Consumers unknowingly receive imitations rather than authentic works, with Sony Music reporting over 260,000 takedown requests for AI deepfakes of their artists, describing the situation as an “uphill struggle.”
Nadler cautioned that without clear legislative boundaries, AI companies like OpenAI and Suno will continue to exploit creators’ works. He condemned the Trump administration’s DOJ for effectively granting permission for mass intellectual property theft under the guise of fair use.
Concluding his argument, Nadler asserted that America can lead in artificial intelligence innovation without relying on stolen content. He called on Congress to recognize “stolen intelligence” as a liability and to enact laws that protect the rights of authors, artists, and creators against unauthorized AI exploitation.
Congressman Nadler Urges Legislative Action to Prevent AI Firms from Exploiting Creators’ Intellectual Property In a recent op-ed and legal filing, Congressman Jerrold Nadler warns that artificial intelligence companies are infringing on intellectual property rights by training models on copyrighted works without permission. He c... Read the full IIPLA article: https://iipla.org/news/congressman-nadler-urges-legislative-action-to-prevent-ai-firms-from-exploiting-creators-intellectual-property