This edition of FRAND Quarterly provides a comprehensive update on recent developments shaping the global FRAND (Fair, Reasonable, and Non-Discriminatory) licensing environment. Central to this update are the contrasting FRAND determinations issued by courts in the United Kingdom, Germany, and China concerning the Samsung v ZTE dispute, which collectively illustrate the complexity and divergence in approaches to SEP licensing worldwide.
In the UK, Meade J adopted a comparables-based methodology, anchoring the royalty assessment on a 2020 ZTE-Apple license. Adjustments were made to account for ZTE’s financial pressures due to US sanctions and its relative inexperience in 5G SEP negotiations at the time. This approach led to a royalty valuation of $392 million payable by Samsung to ZTE. The court dismissed Samsung’s licenses with Ericsson, Nokia, and InterDigital as inappropriate comparables, citing differences in portfolio composition and the influence of non-FRAND factors such as injunction threats. Additionally, Meade J clarified that the 2021 license between the parties covered 4G SEPs re-declared to 5G, leaving only “5G Only” SEPs subject to the new agreement, and ruled that no royalties were due for 2024 due to a covenant not to sue.
Conversely, the Munich Regional Court rejected all disclosed agreements as comparables, noting that neither the 2021 license nor the 2020 ZTE-Apple license was presented during proceedings. The court applied a top-down methodology consistent with its recent FRAND decisions, assuming an 8% aggregate royalty burden on a $170 average device price. After apportioning ZTE’s share and applying discounts for Samsung’s high sales volume and conduct during negotiations, the court established an upper bound royalty of $798 million. The court found ZTE’s undisclosed offer to be FRAND within this corridor. Further adjustments led the court to a cross-license valuation of $640 million, factoring in discounts for uncertainties and portfolio valuation incentives. The Munich court also published new “FRAND guidelines” outlining its approach to such cases.
The Chongqing Intermediate People’s Court in China employed a hybrid approach, combining comparables and top-down analyses. It accepted the 2021 license as a comparator for 2G-4G SEPs and relied on a Samsung-Nokia license alongside a top-down calculation for 5G SEPs. The court favored the Samsung-Nokia agreement over others due to the absence of litigation influence and business similarities. Applying geographic discounts and apportioning the aggregate royalty burden, the court determined a royalty range of $717 to $787 million, deeming ZTE’s $731 million offer FRAND.
Beyond these determinations, the report highlights ongoing evolution in interim relief mechanisms. The UK courts refined their “mid-point” approach to interim license declarations in Warner Bros. Discovery & Paramount v Nokia. The Delhi High Court reaffirmed provisional security measures in Malikie v Xiaomi and InterDigital v Transsion, while the Brazilian court adopted a phased FRAND review in Acer v Nokia.
In a landmark ruling, the UK Supreme Court confirmed that prospective licensees may initiate FRAND claims against patent pools, potentially broadening avenues for challenging licensing terms.
The Munich 7th Civil Chamber’s unilateral publication of FRAND guidelines marks a notable development, providing transparency into its methodology and even engaging in notional royalty rate calculations.
The multi-jurisdictional dispute between InterDigital and Amazon, marked by jurisdictional conflicts between the UK courts and the Unified Patent Court (UPC) in Germany, culminated in an agreement to resolve all pending litigation through binding arbitration. This settlement followed a series of contentious rulings, including the UPC’s broad anti-suit injunction and subsequent enforcement actions, which raised significant comity concerns and highlighted the challenges of coordinating FRAND litigation across jurisdictions.
Finally, the update briefly notes a February 2026 jury verdict in the Eastern District of Texas, where Optis’s claims of infringement on five 4G standard-essential patents against Apple were rejected. This follows a prior 2020 trial that had found infringement and awarded damages, subsequently vacated in 2021 for a new trial on damages.
These developments collectively underscore the dynamic and often divergent landscape of FRAND licensing and SEP enforcement globally, reflecting varying judicial philosophies, procedural frameworks, and market considerations across key jurisdictions.
Divergent Global Court Rulings Highlight Complexities in Samsung v ZTE FRAND Licensing Dispute The latest FRAND Quarterly examines significant developments in the global standard-essential patent (SEP) licensing landscape, focusing on competing FRAND determinations in the Samsung v ZTE case across the UK, Germany... Read the full IIPLA article: https://iipla.org/news/divergent-global-court-rulings-highlight-complexities-in-samsung-v-zte-frand-licensing-dispute