The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit issued several significant rulings on September 17. In Carnegie Institute of Washington v. Fenix Diamonds LLC, the court affirmed an attorneys’ fee award against Carnegie Institute after finding its patent infringement claims related to lab-grown diamond production were objectively baseless. Evidence showed Fenix’s manufacturing process involved extensive non-monocrystalline growth, whereas Carnegie’s patents covered methods with only insubstantial polycrystalline growth, undermining the infringement allegations.
On the same day, the Federal Circuit vacated and remanded a Patent Trial and Appeal Board (PTAB) decision in In re Incept LLC. The PTAB had affirmed a patent examiner’s rejection of claims directed to a medical catheter featuring an anchoring strain with ridges forming a "flow barrier." The Federal Circuit found the PTAB erred by construing "flow barrier" as merely positional without requiring a sealing effect, which the court held was supported by the claim language under the broadest reasonable interpretation.
In the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit, oral arguments were heard on September 17 in Penn State v. Vintage Brands. The case involves Vintage Brands’ appeal of a jury verdict finding trademark infringement for selling unlicensed merchandise bearing vintage Penn State logos. Vintage Brands contends the logos are in the public domain and merely ornamental, supported by disclaimers on its website, arguing no likelihood of consumer confusion. The district court jury disagreed, finding that Vintage’s products created an association with Penn State.
The Ninth Circuit issued a ruling on September 16 in Doe v. GitHub, Inc., affirming the dismissal of copyright claims under the Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA) brought by anonymous plaintiffs. The plaintiffs alleged GitHub’s AI-powered Codex and Copilot tools infringed their copyrights by using their software projects. While the court recognized the plaintiffs’ standing, it rejected their claims, holding that the AI tools created new works and did not remove or alter copyright management information. The plaintiffs had also forfeited their "input" theory of infringement.
On the legislative front, the U.S. Senate advanced the Protect College Sports Act on September 17 by a 77 to 22 vote to proceed toward final passage. The bill, which codifies name, image, and likeness (NIL) rights for collegiate athletes, was amended to require the NCAA to ensure school compliance and to reduce the waiting period for schools transferring between Power Four conferences. Earlier in the week, the Senate invoked cloture by a 74 to 24 vote, following bipartisan support and advocacy from collegiate athletes and coaches.
U.S. Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO) Director John Squires announced on September 16 that trademark filings have increased by 11% during the first nine months of 2026 compared to the same period in 2025, reaching 673,000 filings. Squires made these remarks at the third annual Washington D.C. Conference hosted by the University of Southern California’s Gould School of Law.
In other notable developments, UMG Recordings filed a copyright infringement and deceptive trade practices lawsuit against digital music distributor DistroKid on September 15 in the District of Delaware. UMG alleges DistroKid misleads consumers by marketing AI-generated music as artist-backed content, flooding platforms with low-quality "AI slop" and diverting revenues from legitimate artists.
Additionally, Chinese technology company Huawei announced new AI computing chips, including the Atlas 960 SuperPoD cluster, on September 17. The announcement precedes a high-profile meeting between U.S. President Donald Trump and Chinese President Xi Jinping in Washington, D.C.
These developments underscore ongoing judicial scrutiny of AI-related IP issues, evolving trademark enforcement, and legislative efforts impacting collegiate sports and IP rights.
Federal Circuit Affirms Fees in Lab-Grown Diamond Dispute; Ninth Circuit Rejects DMCA Output Claims Against GitHub; Third Circuit Hears Vintage Sports Logo Trademark Appeal This week’s IP developments feature the Federal Circuit’s affirmation of attorneys’ fees against Carnegie Institute for baseless lab-grown diamond patent claims and reversal of PTAB’s claim construction in a medical cat... Read the full IIPLA article: https://iipla.org/news/federal-circuit-affirms-fees-in-lab-grown-diamond-dispute-ninth-circuit-rejects-dmca-output-claims-against-github-third-circuit-hears-vintage-sports-logo-trademark-appeal