Coke Morgan Stewart, president and CEO of the Council for Innovation Promotion and former deputy under secretary of Commerce for intellectual property as well as deputy director of the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office, recently addressed the vital role of intellectual property (IP) rights in the American economy and innovation landscape.
Stewart’s remarks come amid several high-profile copyright lawsuits filed by major publications—including The New York Times, Chicago Tribune, and USA Today—against OpenAI, the company behind ChatGPT. These lawsuits allege that OpenAI used their copyrighted articles to train its AI models without authorization, raising questions about the scope of copyright protections in the age of artificial intelligence.
OpenAI defends its practices by invoking the "fair use" doctrine, a legal principle permitting limited use of copyrighted material without permission. The U.S. Department of Justice recently submitted a brief supporting OpenAI's broad interpretation of fair use, signaling federal backing for expansive AI training practices.
While Stewart acknowledges the importance of maintaining U.S. leadership in AI development—referred to by former President Trump as "super intelligence"—he cautions that federal agencies and lawmakers must avoid undermining the property rights that underpin the nation’s economic framework.
"Copyrights, patents, and other intellectual property protections give authors, inventors, and small companies an incentive to innovate and a way to compete against big companies and wealthy elites who would otherwise take their good ideas without compensation," Stewart explained. He described IP as the "great equalizer" that levels the playing field between small innovators and powerful corporations, enabling anyone with a good idea to succeed.
Stewart emphasized that preserving intellectual property protections is essential to sustaining the flow of new products, fostering entrepreneurship, and creating jobs.
Tracing the historical evolution of IP, Stewart noted that for much of human history, ideas were not considered property. It was only during the Enlightenment that governments and philosophers recognized the fairness and economic potential of granting creators exclusive rights for limited periods.
This principle was enshrined in the U.S. Constitution’s Intellectual Property Clause, which empowers Congress "To promote the Progress of Science and useful Arts, by securing for limited Times to Authors and Inventors the exclusive Right to their respective Writings and Discoveries." This clause uniquely links a public objective with private property rights, granting inventors and authors a temporary monopoly to commercialize their ideas.
Stewart illustrated the transformative impact of IP protections through historical and modern examples. Elias Howe, a machinist from Massachusetts, patented a practical sewing machine in 1846. Despite lacking wealth or corporate backing, Howe’s patent gave him enforceable ownership, enabling him to compete against larger manufacturers and revolutionize clothing production.
Similarly, Thomas Edison, who began as a telegraph operator and news vendor, leveraged the patent system to secure over a thousand U.S. patents. These patents helped him attract investment and commercialize innovations such as recorded sound and electric lighting.
In contemporary times, author J.K. Rowling’s copyright ownership of the Harry Potter series allowed her to partner with publishers and license her work for films, theme parks, and more, ultimately becoming a billionaire.
Inventor Aaron Krause’s patents on an improved sponge enabled him to secure investment on the television show Shark Tank, turning Scrub Daddy into a business generating approximately $220 million annually.
Stewart also highlighted how IP protections empower small companies to defend their innovations against larger competitors. Medical technology firm Acumed, which began as a family business, patented orthopedic devices including a specialized nail for fracture repair. When a major competitor copied the technology despite legal warnings, Acumed successfully sued for willful infringement, obtaining a permanent injunction against further sales.
Although the infringing company appealed and the Federal Circuit initially vacated the injunction following the Supreme Court’s 2006 eBay v. MercExchange decision—which set stricter standards for injunctions—Acumed’s case underscores the critical role of IP rights in enabling smaller innovators to protect their inventions.
Stewart’s insights underscore the enduring importance of intellectual property as a driver of innovation, economic opportunity, and fair competition in the United States, especially as emerging technologies like AI challenge existing legal frameworks.
Former USPTO Deputy Director Highlights Intellectual Property as Key to Innovation and Economic Equality Coke Morgan Stewart, former deputy under secretary of Commerce for intellectual property and ex-deputy director of the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office, underscores intellectual property rights as the foundational 'grea... Read the full IIPLA article: https://iipla.org/news/former-uspto-deputy-director-highlights-intellectual-property-as-key-to-innovation-and-economic-equality