In a significant judgment dated September 25, 2023, the Gujarat High Court in Hasmukhbhai Bhagwanbhai Patel v. Husenali Anwarali Charaniya revisited the principles governing territorial jurisdiction in trademark and copyright infringement suits. The case arose from a trademark suit No.1 of 2023 filed by the appellant before the District Court, Dahod, seeking permanent injunction, accounts of profit, and damages under the Trade Marks Act, 1999 and the Copyright Act, 1957, concerning the use of the trademark "KRANTI KAKA" related to betel nuts.
The plaintiff invoked the territorial jurisdiction of the Dahod District Court based on invoices evidencing sales within that jurisdiction. However, the defendant challenged the maintainability of the suit, filing an application to reject the plaint for lack of jurisdiction. The defendant contended that neither party’s business operations nor the alleged infringement occurred within Dahod district. The Learned Additional District Judge (ADJ), Dahod, by order dated April 18, 2023, dismissed the plaint under Order 7 Rule 11 of the Civil Procedure Code (CPC), 1908, citing lack of territorial jurisdiction.
The Court examined the interplay between the general jurisdictional provisions under Section 20 of the CPC and the specific provisions under the Trade Marks Act and Copyright Act. Section 20 of the CPC permits a plaintiff to institute a suit where the defendant resides, carries on business, or where the cause of action arises wholly or in part. This provision aims to prevent undue hardship to defendants by avoiding forcing them to litigate in distant forums.
Conversely, Section 62(2) of the Copyright Act, 1957, and Section 134(2) of the Trade Marks Act, 1999, each contain non-obstante clauses stating "notwithstanding anything contained in the Civil Procedure Code," allowing plaintiffs to file suits in courts where they themselves reside or carry on business. These provisions were enacted to facilitate plaintiffs’ access to justice by expanding their choice of forum, particularly where Section 20 of the CPC might restrict them.
The Supreme Court’s landmark ruling in Indian Performing Right Society Ltd. v. Sanjay Dalia clarified that Sections 62(2) and 134(2) provide additional forums for plaintiffs but do not override Section 20 of the CPC. The Court emphasized that these provisions prevent plaintiffs from being deterred by the inconvenience of distant courts but also require safeguards against abuse. It held that suits should be instituted where the cause of action arises wholly or partly at the plaintiff’s place of residence or business, ensuring a balance between plaintiff convenience and defendant protection.
Similarly, the Delhi High Court in Burger King Corporation v. Techchand Shewakramani & Ors. affirmed that Sections 134 of the Trade Marks Act and 62 of the Copyright Act are supplementary to Section 20 of the CPC. If a cause of action exists within a court’s territorial jurisdiction under Section 20, there is no need to invoke the specific statutory provisions.
In the present case, the plaintiff resided and operated a factory in Surat, while the defendant conducted business in Moraiya and Ahmedabad and resided in Wadhwan. The plaintiff’s choice to file suit in Dahod was based solely on sales occurring there. The Gujarat High Court observed that neither party resided or carried on business in Dahod, and the plaintiff failed to justify why the suit was not filed in Surat or Surendranagar, where the defendant resided or conducted business.
The Court underscored that the legislative intent behind Sections 62 and 134 is to provide plaintiffs with an additional forum, not to compel defendants to litigate in distant or unrelated jurisdictions. It clarified that mere sales in a remote location do not suffice to establish territorial jurisdiction. Plaintiffs must demonstrate a clear and unequivocal connection to the forum to avoid abuse of process or harassment of defendants.
This ruling reinforces the principle that territorial jurisdiction in trademark and copyright suits must be established with precision, respecting both statutory provisions and the overarching objectives of procedural fairness. It serves as a critical reminder for litigants to carefully consider jurisdictional grounds before initiating infringement proceedings.
The article provides a general overview and does not substitute for specialized legal advice tailored to specific circumstances.
Gujarat High Court Clarifies Territorial Jurisdiction in Trademark and Copyright Infringement Suits The Gujarat High Court revisited territorial jurisdiction principles in trademark and copyright infringement cases, underscoring that plaintiffs cannot invoke jurisdiction based solely on remote sales without a substant... Read the full IIPLA article: https://iipla.org/news/gujarat-high-court-clarifies-territorial-jurisdiction-in-trademark-and-copyright-infringement-suits