In a significant judgment delivered on 10 February 2026, the United States District Court for the District of Massachusetts addressed the intersection of copyright infringement claims and insurance coverage exclusions. The case involved a real estate agency (the Plaintiff) and its insurer (the Defendant) concerning coverage under a Real Estate Agents Errors and Omissions Liability Policy.
The Plaintiff, primarily engaged in residential real estate brokerage, purchased the policy on 5 January 2024, effective from 7 February 2024 to 7 February 2025. The policy obligated the Defendant to defend and indemnify the Plaintiff against claims arising from negligent acts, errors, omissions, or personal injury related to professional services.
The dispute arose when the Plaintiff used architectural drawings and designs in marketing a newly built home in Bridgewater, Massachusetts. The architect who created these materials sued the Plaintiff for copyright infringement on 27 September 2024. The Plaintiff promptly requested defense coverage from the Defendant on 4 October 2024.
The Defendant denied coverage on 24 October 2024, citing two policy exclusions. After the Plaintiff challenged this denial, the Defendant reaffirmed its refusal on 30 December 2024, additionally invoking Exclusion A.8(d). This exclusion barred coverage for disputes involving "conversion, misappropriation, commingling, improper use, theft, embezzlement or defalcation of funds, account information or other property."
In March 2025, the Plaintiff filed a complaint in Bristol Superior Court seeking a declaratory judgment to affirm coverage entitlement and damages for legal expenses incurred due to the alleged breach of contract by the insurer.
The central legal question was whether Exclusion A.8(d) applied to exclude coverage for the copyright infringement claim, thereby relieving the insurer of its duty to defend and indemnify.
Applying Massachusetts law, the court emphasized that insurance policies are interpreted according to general contract principles, focusing on what an objectively reasonable insured would expect. The insurer bears the burden of proving that an exclusion applies, and exclusions must be narrowly construed with ambiguities resolved against the insurer.
The court employed the canons of ejusdem generis and noscitur a sociis to interpret "other property" in the exclusion. Since the preceding terms—"funds" and "account information"—referred to financial assets, "other property" was limited to similar financial assets rather than encompassing all property types, including intangible intellectual property.
Regarding the terms "misappropriation" and "improper use," the court noted that the other listed acts in the exclusion (such as "conversion," "theft," and "embezzlement") denote intentional torts. Thus, these terms should not be extended to cover claims based on negligence or statutory violations like copyright infringement. The absence of the term "infringement" in the exclusion further supported this interpretation.
The court also considered the policy’s purpose and the reasonable expectations of the insured. Real estate agents commonly use marketing materials that may inadvertently infringe on copyrights. If such inadvertent infringement were excluded under "misappropriation" or "improper use," it would negate coverage for a substantial portion of risks the insured would anticipate being protected against.
Ultimately, the court held that the insurer had a duty to defend and indemnify the Plaintiff in the underlying copyright infringement action, rejecting the insurer’s reliance on Exclusion A.8(d).
This ruling holds particular relevance for the South African insurance industry and jurisprudence. South African law similarly applies the contra proferentem rule, construing ambiguous contract terms against the drafter—often the insurer. The Massachusetts court’s approach offers a comparative perspective on narrowly interpreting exclusion clauses in intellectual property insurance coverage.
The judgment highlights the critical need for insurers to draft clear and specific exclusions when addressing intellectual property risks and for insured parties to understand the scope of their coverage in the evolving landscape of IP-related liabilities.
Massachusetts Court Rules Against Insurer’s Exclusion in Copyright Infringement Coverage Dispute A recent ruling by the United States District Court for the District of Massachusetts clarifies the scope of insurance policy exclusions related to copyright infringement claims. The court held that an insurer’s exclusi... Read the full IIPLA article: https://iipla.org/news/massachusetts-court-rules-against-insurer-s-exclusion-in-copyright-infringement-coverage-dispute