Nintendo has come under scrutiny from intellectual property lawyers following the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office's (USPTO) grant of Patent No. 12,403,397, which broadly covers the mechanic of summoning a character to engage in battles within a game. This patent, issued without opposition, encapsulates a fundamental gameplay element famously used in Pokémon titles but also prevalent in many other games such as Persona, Digimon, and Elden Ring.
The patent was filed in 2023 and describes a process involving a computing device storing a game where players can summon a “sub character” — a non-player character like a Pokémon — to fight either immediately upon summoning if an opponent is present or after being directed to move towards another character. The patent outlines mutually exclusive scenarios for summoning and initiating combat, culminating in an automatic battle sequence.
Industry observers and legal experts have expressed alarm over the patent's scope. Games Fray highlighted that the patent’s claims could potentially expose numerous games employing similar mechanics to infringement lawsuits by Nintendo. The broad nature of the patent raises concerns about its impact on creativity and innovation within the gaming industry.
Prominent IP expert Florian Mueller publicly condemned the patent, stating on social media that Nintendo “should never” have been granted such a patent. Mueller also noted that the Japan Patent Office (JPO) had similarly issued an “outrageous” amended patent related to the same matter, which Nintendo is using in litigation against Palworld in Japan.
Video game patent attorney Kirk Sigmon echoed this sentiment, telling PC Gamer that the patent claims were "in no way allowable," suggesting they should not have passed examination standards. The criticism underscores a broader issue with patents covering fundamental game mechanics, which are often viewed as stifling competition and innovation.
Don McGowan, former chief legal officer at The Pokémon Company, offered a more measured perspective to Eurogamer, predicting that the patent would likely be ignored by other developers. He expressed confidence that any lawsuits based on this patent would be challenged with extensive prior art, contrasting this case with previous controversial patents such as Bandai Namco’s loading screen patent.
In addition to Patent No. 12,403,397, Nintendo also holds U.S. Patent No. 12,409,387, which protects the “smooth switching of riding objects” mechanic. These patents complement a portfolio that includes protection for the use of capture items, like Poké Balls, further solidifying Nintendo’s IP claims over core Pokémon gameplay elements.
These developments come amid ongoing litigation between Nintendo, The Pokémon Company, and Pocketpair, the developer of Palworld. The dispute involves three patents granted by the JPO in 2024, two covering monster capture and release mechanics and one relating to riding characters. Notably, these patents are divisional filings derived from earlier patents dating back to 2021, suggesting a strategic effort by Nintendo to target Palworld’s allegedly infringing features.
Pocketpair has responded by modifying Palworld’s gameplay mechanics to avoid infringement. A November 2024 update removed the ability to summon Pals by throwing Pokéball-like spheres, instead having them materialize beside the player. Further changes in May 2025 altered gliding mechanics to use Pal-buffed equipment rather than direct interaction with Glider Pals. In July 2025, Nintendo and The Pokémon Company amended the wording of one of their patents involved in the litigation.
The controversy surrounding Nintendo’s “summon character and let it fight” patent highlights ongoing tensions in the gaming industry over the scope and enforcement of patents on fundamental gameplay mechanics. As legal battles continue, the case serves as a critical example of the challenges in balancing intellectual property rights with the need to preserve creative freedom and innovation in game development.
Nintendo's Controversial 'Summon and Fight' Pokémon Patent Sparks Industry-Wide IP Concerns Nintendo was awarded U.S. Patent No. 12,403,397, covering a game mechanic central to Pokémon and similar titles—summoning a character to fight automatically. The patent, granted without objection, has drawn sharp critic... Read the full IIPLA article: https://iipla.org/news/nintendo-s-controversial-summon-and-fight-pok-mon-patent-sparks-industry-wide-ip-concerns