A small San Diego-based haptics company, Taction Technology, has won what legal experts are calling the largest patent verdict in American history. On Friday, a federal jury in the Southern District of California found that Apple infringed two of Taction's patents covering tactile transducers—the vibration hardware that provides haptic feedback in devices like phones and watches. The jury awarded Taction more than $5.7 billion in damages.
Taction argued that Apple's Taptic Engine, embedded in iPhones and Apple Watches, utilized its patented technology without a license. Apple denied the allegations, asserting that its Taptic Engine is "fundamentally different" from Taction's inventions and announced plans to appeal the verdict.
The litigation has a complex procedural history. Taction filed suit in 2021, but in 2023, Judge Robinson excluded testimony from Taction's technical expert and granted Apple summary judgment, effectively ending the case before trial. The Federal Circuit later revived the suit, leading to a trial that began on September 14. After parts of two days of deliberation, a seven-member jury ruled in favor of Taction.
While the jury found infringement, it did not find that Apple's conduct was willful. This distinction is significant because under the Patent Act, judges may increase damages up to threefold in cases of willful infringement. Without such a finding, Taction's prospects for enhanced damages are limited.
The case also draws attention to the role of third-party litigation funding (TPLF). Court disclosures reveal that Taction's litigation was financed by Gronostaj Investments LLC and Kenosha Investments LP. Kenosha has been identified in separate litigation as an indirect subsidiary of Burford Capital, one of the world's largest litigation funders.
This verdict arrives amid heightened scrutiny and regulatory efforts targeting TPLF, particularly from the insurance industry. In June, North Carolina became the first U.S. state to ban third-party litigation funding outright, making it unlawful to finance civil litigation in exchange for a stake in the outcome. Violations carry civil penalties up to $50,000 per incident. The legislation passed overwhelmingly, with a 112-0 vote in the House and 45-1 in the Senate.
Other states, including Georgia, Montana, Indiana, and Louisiana, have enacted laws requiring disclosure or registration of litigation funders or limiting their control over cases. However, these reforms have geographic and procedural limits. For example, North Carolina's ban applies only to cases within the state, whereas the Taction case was tried in California.
At the federal level, Senators Chuck Grassley, Thom Tillis, John Kennedy, and John Cornyn introduced the Litigation Funding Transparency Act of 2026 in February. The bill would mandate disclosure of funders and funding agreements and prohibit funders from directing litigation strategy or settlement decisions. The American Property Casualty Insurance Association supports the bill, which currently applies only to class actions, multidistrict litigation, and coordinated proceedings involving 100 or more cases. Single-plaintiff patent suits like Taction's are excluded. The bill remains in committee.
The federal judiciary's Advisory Committee on Civil Rules also examined a potential disclosure rule last October and decided to continue studying the issue.
Insurers are responding through policy measures as well. The Insurance Services Office (ISO) has introduced an optional "Litigation Funding Mutual Disclosure" endorsement for 2026 commercial liability programs, enabling carriers to obtain funding details in coverage disputes. The Council of Insurance Agents & Brokers has linked the presence of litigation funding to reduced availability and increased pricing in key liability insurance lines.
Industry experts anticipate that even with bans and disclosure requirements, reductions in claims costs will be gradual. Gary Leonard, senior vice president of general liability claims at Gallagher Bassett, told Insurance Business that North Carolina's law marks a shift from transparency efforts to direct restrictions on outside litigation capital. Leonard noted that such laws could influence litigation dynamics by reducing funding-driven pressure on claim severity and might serve as models for other states.
He cautioned, however, that the impact depends on the extent of adoption by other jurisdictions and how plaintiff attorneys adapt their strategies over time.
San Diego Firm Secures $5.7 Billion Patent Verdict Against Apple, Spotlighting Litigation Funding Debate A federal jury in California awarded Taction Technology over $5.7 billion in damages after finding Apple infringed patents related to tactile transducers. The case, financed by major litigation funders, highlights tensi... Read the full IIPLA article: https://iipla.org/news/san-diego-firm-secures-5-7-billion-patent-verdict-against-apple-spotlighting-litigation-funding-debate