The principle that U.S. law generally does not apply beyond its borders, known as the presumption against extraterritoriality, has long shaped American legal doctrine. This presumption balances U.S. sovereignty with respect for other nations’ legal systems, ensuring that U.S. statutes do not overreach internationally without clear congressional intent.
Intellectual property (IP) law is no exception to this principle. However, a recent ruling by the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit in Motorola Solutions Inc. v. Hytera Communications Corp. has notably expanded the extraterritorial reach of the Defend Trade Secrets Act (DTSA).
The case presented a question of first impression regarding whether the DTSA applies extraterritorially. Like many statutes, the DTSA is subject to the presumption against extraterritoriality unless Congress clearly indicates otherwise.
To resolve this, the Seventh Circuit applied a two-step framework: first, determining whether the statute’s language clearly indicates extraterritorial application; and second, assessing whether the conduct relevant to the statute’s focus occurred within the United States or abroad.
The court found that the DTSA’s plain language explicitly rebuts the presumption against extraterritoriality. This clear congressional intent means the DTSA may apply to conduct occurring outside the United States, and the court did not need to proceed to the second step of the analysis.
This ruling is unprecedented in the IP context, as it contrasts with the more limited extraterritorial applications seen in other IP areas such as copyright and trademark law.
Regarding copyright law, the Seventh Circuit reaffirmed that the Copyright Act does not explicitly rebut the presumption against extraterritoriality. Consequently, courts apply the second step of the framework, focusing on whether the relevant infringing conduct occurred domestically.
In copyright cases, courts have developed the predicate act doctrine, which permits recovery for foreign infringement only if an initial act of infringement occurred in the United States and that domestic infringement was directly linked to the foreign infringement.
This doctrine imposes a narrow scope for extraterritorial application of the Copyright Act, requiring a domestic nexus to the foreign infringement.
Trademark law follows a similar restrictive approach. In the 2023 Supreme Court case Abitron Austria GmbH v. Hetronic International Inc., the Court held that the Lanham Act does not explicitly authorize extraterritorial application.
Therefore, courts examine whether the alleged infringement involved unauthorized use in commerce within the United States that is connected to foreign conduct.
Only when such domestic unauthorized use exists can the Lanham Act apply extraterritorially, reflecting a limited scope akin to copyright law.
In summary, the Seventh Circuit’s decision in Motorola Solutions v. Hytera marks a significant expansion of the DTSA’s extraterritorial reach, diverging from the narrower extraterritorial applications of the Copyright Act and Lanham Act. This ruling underscores the importance of statutory language and congressional intent in determining the international scope of U.S. IP laws.
Seventh Circuit Expands Extraterritorial Reach of Defend Trade Secrets Act in Landmark Ruling In a pivotal July ruling, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit held that the Defend Trade Secrets Act (DTSA) expressly permits extraterritorial application, marking a significant departure from traditional... Read the full IIPLA article: https://iipla.org/news/seventh-circuit-expands-extraterritorial-reach-of-defend-trade-secrets-act-in-landmark-ruling