A recent trademark dispute between J.M. Smucker Co. and Trader Joe’s over the shape and packaging of frozen peanut butter and jelly sandwiches has highlighted the crucial role of brand enforcement records in trademark litigation. The U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Ohio ruled in August that Smucker’s claims of trademark infringement, dilution, trade dress violation, and unfair competition under the Lanham Act could proceed, rejecting Trader Joe’s motion to dismiss and its attempt to change venue.
The dispute centers on the distinctive rounded, crustless, crimped-edge design of Smucker’s Uncrustables sandwiches and the associated packaging imagery. Trader Joe’s argued that its sandwich features a “squircle” shape—a square with rounded corners—distinguishing it from Smucker’s round Uncrustables design. However, the court found this distinction insufficient to dismiss the case at the pleading stage.
Judge John R. Adams emphasized that Smucker’s complaint adequately alleged the brand’s fame by detailing substantial advertising investment, significant sales volume, widespread public recognition, and a documented history of protecting the design in the marketplace. These factors collectively supported a plausible claim that the sandwich design is “famous” under the dilution provisions of the Lanham Act.
While Smucker reportedly invested nearly a billion dollars in the Uncrustables brand over 25 years, the court’s ruling focused on the scope and substance of the allegations rather than the monetary amount. Under the Lanham Act, only marks that achieve a certain level of fame are protected from dilution, and such fame must be demonstrated through consistent evidence of consumer recognition and brand significance.
Trader Joe’s also raised a functionality defense, arguing that the crimped sealed edge serves a practical engineering purpose by sealing in the filling, enabling freezing, and facilitating handling. Trademark law prohibits trade dress protection for functional product features. This issue remains unresolved, but the court held that Smucker’s two decades of evidence suggesting non-functionality suffices to move the case forward to trial.
The ruling underscores that the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office does not police the marketplace or notify trademark owners of potentially infringing marks. Brand owners must proactively monitor and enforce their rights. The critical window to object to a trademark application is the 30-day publication period following examination clearance, with possible extensions up to 180 days. After this period, challenges become slower and more costly, requiring petitions before the Trademark Trial and Appeal Board or federal court litigation.
Smucker’s ability to demonstrate fame and an enforcement record in this case exemplifies the benefits of consistent trademark monitoring and documentation over many years. While Smucker’s budget is substantial, smaller brand owners can build comparable records by tracking filings near their marks and acting promptly within the objection window.
For trademark counsel and in-house practitioners, the court’s reliance on advertising spend, sales data, registration history, and public recognition to credit Smucker’s fame allegations confirms that maintaining detailed brand investment and enforcement records is essential litigation preparation rather than mere administrative overhead.
Although the ruling is procedural and does not resolve issues of functionality, distinctiveness, or the precise scope of Smucker’s trade dress rights, it grants the brand owner sufficient credibility to advance the case while setting aside Trader Joe’s shape-based defense.
The decision also highlights the importance of early trademark watching services that flag potentially conflicting applications before or during the publication period, allowing timely evaluation and response. Monitoring related trademark classes is as important as identical ones, since infringing filings often occur in adjacent product categories.
Beyond trademark filings, brand owners should vigilantly monitor the marketplace for unregistered uses that may infringe rights, including new storefronts, online marketplaces like Amazon or Etsy, and social media platforms such as Instagram and TikTok. Google Alerts and periodic searches across relevant sales channels can detect unauthorized uses that do not appear in the Official Gazette.
Early detection of similar brand names or handles on digital platforms enables faster, less costly resolution through platform dispute mechanisms, often serving as a first warning sign of potential infringement.
In sum, the Smucker case demonstrates that a robust enforcement record and proactive monitoring strategy are critical tools for brand owners seeking to protect trade dress and trademark rights in a competitive marketplace.
Smucker’s Trademark Case Against Trader Joe’s Highlights Importance of Brand Enforcement Records The U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Ohio denied Trader Joe’s motion to dismiss Smucker’s lawsuit alleging trademark infringement, dilution, and trade dress violation over the design of frozen peanut but... Read the full IIPLA article: https://iipla.org/news/smucker-s-trademark-case-against-trader-joe-s-highlights-importance-of-brand-enforcement-records