A long-standing dispute over revisions to South Korea's Patent Attorney Act has moved closer to resolution following a recent agreement among key stakeholders. Independent lawmaker Kim Jong-min, the Ministry of Intellectual Property, and the Korean Bar Association reached consensus on November 18 to narrow the scope of the proposed confidentiality rights for patent attorneys and their clients.
The parties agreed that the new confidentiality right would apply exclusively to evidence discovery proceedings in litigation or administrative trials. Crucially, this right would not extend to situations where police or other investigative authorities have initiated probes based on specific allegations. This compromise aims to balance the protection of corporate trade secrets with the need for effective law enforcement.
If enacted in its current form, the bill will provide patent attorneys and their clients a legal foundation to refuse disclosure of case-related materials during discovery phases. The confidentiality right encompasses communications exchanged for professional purposes and documents prepared in connection with patent cases.
Kim Jong-min introduced the bill in January as the lead sponsor. The legislation initially proposed broad confidentiality rights alongside new duties for patent attorneys, intending to align their protections with those codified for attorneys under a revised Attorney-at-Law Act effective February 20, 2027.
The Ministry of Intellectual Property and Kim emphasized the need for these revisions to prevent exposure of trade secrets and confidential business information during patent litigation. Under current practice, Korean companies' confidentiality in U.S. patent litigation discovery has been recognized based on precedent, but the absence of explicit domestic legal provisions for patent attorneys raised concerns about future recognition.
Despite clearing the standing committee with relative ease, the bill encountered unexpected resistance in the Legislation and Judiciary Committee. The Korean Bar Association opposed the bill, warning that companies might exploit the confidentiality right to conceal evidence of technology theft.
In April, the Bar Association, led by President Kim Jung-wook, issued a statement condemning the bill as "toxic legislation that shakes the foundations of South Korea's judicial system and hands large companies a legal shield for hiding evidence of technology theft."
Nevertheless, Kim and the Ministry maintained that establishing a legal basis for patent attorney confidentiality is essential to protect Korean companies' defense rights and trade secrets in overseas patent disputes. The compromise reached reflects a middle ground that recognizes the confidentiality right while limiting its application.
The revised bill will be resubmitted to the Legislation and Judiciary Committee for further review. Both Kim and the Ministry hope for its passage in the National Assembly plenary session within the current year.
Kim stressed the importance of the confidentiality right for the effective operation of a Korean-style discovery system. "For a Korean-style discovery system to function properly, the confidentiality right must be in place to support it," he said.
He further noted, "Attorneys' confidentiality takes effect on February 20 next year, and unless patent attorneys' confidentiality in technology and patent disputes is introduced before then, the purpose of the Korean-style discovery system will inevitably be undermined."
Kim called for swift legislative deliberation, emphasizing that confidentiality rights for both attorneys and patent attorneys should work complementarily with the discovery system to protect sensitive information.
This development marks a significant step in South Korea's efforts to modernize its intellectual property legal framework, balancing corporate confidentiality with judicial transparency and investigative needs.
South Korea Narrows Patent Attorney Confidentiality Rights to Resolve Legislative Dispute A contentious bill revising South Korea's Patent Attorney Act has advanced toward passage after independent lawmaker Kim Jong-min, the Ministry of Intellectual Property, and the Korean Bar Association agreed to restrict... Read the full IIPLA article: https://iipla.org/news/south-korea-narrows-patent-attorney-confidentiality-rights-to-resolve-legislative-dispute