Most major disputes over video codec patents conclude with licensing agreements or private settlements, leaving unresolved the critical question of patent validity. Despite billions of dollars exchanging hands annually for licensing portfolios, the strength of these patents is rarely tested in court. This dynamic raises the question: can media streaming companies and other implementers adopt a more effective approach to managing codec IP risks?
Industry experts with extensive experience in video coding litigation and licensing suggest a proactive strategy is essential. Such an approach involves assessing patent validity earlier in the licensing cycle, rather than negotiating or settling after infringement complaints arise. This shift is particularly timely given the upcoming AV2 codec adoption cycle, slated for release in June 2026.
Two procedural mechanisms—the inter partes review (IPR) before the U.S. Patent Trial and Appeal Board (PTAB) and oppositions before the European Patent Office (EPO)—have partially illuminated the prior art underlying codec patents. These forums offer cost-effective avenues to challenge patent validity without resorting to full litigation. However, invalidity challenges remain the exception rather than the norm, as many patent holders and licensees prefer to negotiate around validity concerns. Some parties assume patents are valid because others have licensed them, while others fear that challenging patents within a pool could provoke widespread infringement claims.
The article argues that validity can be determined earlier and more economically than traditional litigation timelines suggest. For streaming platforms most exposed to AV2’s forthcoming adoption, understanding codec patent claims and conducting thorough prior art searches before licensing negotiations is foundational to risk management.
Modern video codecs share a common architecture built on three core operations: prediction, transform and quantisation, and entropy coding. Patents typically claim incremental refinements within this framework, such as improved block partitioning or more efficient signalling schemes. Because successive codec standards—from H.264 through HEVC, VVC, AV1, and now AV2—are constructed from these same building blocks, foundational patents often apply across multiple standards, sometimes even to those developed without the patent holder’s involvement.
The royalty-free AV1 codec faced its first patent infringement litigation in March 2026 when Dolby sued Snap in the U.S. District Court for the District of Delaware and in Rio de Janeiro state courts. Dolby accused Snap of using Dolby’s AV1 and HEVC patents without a licence. This case marks the first AV1 patent assertion by an Access Advance licensor and the first AV1 assertion against a streaming platform.
Dolby’s asserted portfolio includes four patents originally filed by General Electric between April 2010 and July 2011, during HEVC’s development, predating AV1’s 2018 specification. These patents relate to prediction, coding structure, and entropy coding. Notably, Dolby never joined the Alliance for Open Media (AOMedia) and made no FRAND commitments for AV1, arguing there is no cap on potential damages and seeking court confirmation of this position.
The dispute is intensifying rather than settling. Dolby filed a third complaint in Brazil in June 2026, asserting additional HEVC patents against Snap. Meanwhile, patent pool administrators Access Advance and Sisvel have assembled AV1 patent pools despite objections from AOMedia. InterDigital has also filed suit alleging Amazon Fire streaming devices infringe its AV1 patents. Sisvel’s AV1 patent list alone contained 1,942 patents as of May 2025.
AV2’s timing is therefore critical. AOMedia finalized AV2 version 1.0.0 on 28 May 2026 and announced it on 9 June 2026. Like AV1, AV2 was developed under AOMedia’s royalty-free patent policy, with members including Amazon, Apple, Google, Microsoft, Mozilla, and Netflix. AV2 offers approximately 30% bitrate savings over AV1 for typical camera-captured video and up to 40% for screen content, HDR, and 8K video, positioning it as a competitor to the royalty-bearing VVC codec. AV2 maintains AV1’s overall encoding framework but introduces significant innovations such as extended recursive partitioning and new prediction modes.
This continuity underscores the importance of understanding patent rights early. AV2 was developed without participation from patent holders most likely to assert claims. The royalty-free label reflects AOMedia’s policy but does not guarantee freedom from third-party patent rights. Before widespread adoption and hardware commitments, patent owners, implementers, and investors must evaluate where relevant rights exist and their robustness.
The case of U.S. Patent 7,515,635, owned by Godo Kaisha IP Bridge 1, illustrates the stakes. This patent was declared essential to multiple codec patent pools, including Access Advance and Sisvel’s VP9 and AV1 pools, credentials that typically command licensing respect and revenue. However, on 3 December 2024, the Federal Circuit affirmed the PTAB’s ruling that all challenged claims of the ’635 patent were unpatentable, invalidating a patent treated as essential to three codec pools.
The procedural history reveals lessons about validity challenges. Unified Patents’ initial IPR petition in January 2021 was denied because it relied solely on applicant-admitted prior art, which is insufficient for IPR. A subsequent ex parte re-examination, supported by independently uncovered patents and printed publications, led to the rejection of every claim. The PTAB affirmed this in March 2023, and the Federal Circuit summarily affirmed in December 2024. The outcome hinged on uncovering the right prior art, not the procedural vehicle.
This case underscores that pool listings, essentiality evaluations, and declaration counts measure inclusion, not patent strength. For implementers and investors, a single diligent prior art search can distinguish an essential patent from an invalid one.
Effective invalidity work requires comprehensive prior art searches covering the most relevant sources. Codec inventions are incremental refinements of ideas publicly circulated years before patent filings. The strongest prior art resides where the engineering discourse occurred.
Standards records are a primary source. Bodies such as MPEG, JCT-VC, and JVET have generated tens of thousands of dated, citable input contributions, meeting documents, and draft specifications. Techniques claimed in patents often appear first in these contributions under different terminology. AV1 and AV2 benefit from an unusually rich open record, including components from Xiph and Mozilla’s Daala (published in 2010), Google’s VP10 (announced 2014), and Cisco’s Thor (published 2015), all predating AV1’s 2018 specification. Open development provides verifiable commit histories and mailing lists, enabling precise prior art identification.
Beyond standards, valuable prior art includes conference and journal literature (such as ICIP, Picture Coding Symposium, and SPIE proceedings), university theses, and archived technical reports from corporate research labs influential in video coding during the 1990s and 2000s. Much of this material predates the priority dates of patents now asserted against AV1 implementations.
Strategic IP Management in Video Coding: Minimizing Licensing and Litigation Costs Ahead of AV2 Adoption As the AV2 video codec nears its 2026 launch, industry stakeholders face increasing patent licensing and litigation risks reminiscent of prior codec disputes. This article examines how early, cost-effective validity cha... Read the full IIPLA article: https://iipla.org/news/strategic-ip-management-in-video-coding-minimizing-licensing-and-litigation-costs-ahead-of-av2-adoption