The Supreme Court of the United States today declined to review the Federal Circuit’s decision in Game Plan, Inc. v. Uninterrupted IP, LLC, thereby affirming the Trademark Trial and Appeal Board’s (TTAB) cancellation of Game Plan’s federal trademark registration and dismissal of its opposition to six intent-to-use applications filed by Uninterrupted IP, LLC (UNIP).
The dispute arose over trademarks incorporating the phrase “MORE THAN AN ATHLETE.” Game Plan filed an application in December 2016 to register a stylized mark reading “I AM MORE THAN AN ATHLETE. GP. GAME PLAN,” which was federally registered on June 5, 2018. The registration covered charitable fundraising services through the sale of t-shirts.
In March 2018, UNIP, a media company affiliated with professional basketball player LeBron James, filed six intent-to-use trademark applications containing the phrases “I AM MORE THAN AN ATHLETE” and “MORE THAN AN ATHLETE.” Game Plan initiated opposition proceedings before the TTAB in November 2018 to challenge these applications.
UNIP responded with an answer and filed a counterclaim in April 2019 seeking cancellation of Game Plan’s registration. UNIP asserted priority based on common law rights acquired through an asset purchase agreement dated February 22, 2019, with DeAndra Alex and her company, More Than An Athlete, Inc. Alex had been selling merchandise bearing the “MORE THAN AN ATHLETE” mark at basketball tournaments and other events since at least May 2013. The assignment conveyed the trademark and all related goodwill to UNIP, which also retained Alex as a consultant.
During the TTAB trial, Game Plan did not submit new evidence but attempted to rely on materials previously filed with its summary judgment motion. The Board declined to consider those materials. On UNIP’s counterclaim, the TTAB found that Alex had established common law rights in the mark predating Game Plan’s December 2016 filing date. The Board further concluded that the 2019 assignment to UNIP was valid and supported by continuing goodwill, rejecting Game Plan’s contention that the assignment was an impermissible assignment in gross.
Consequently, the TTAB canceled Game Plan’s registration and allowed UNIP’s six applications to proceed.
On appeal, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit affirmed the Board’s decision. The court held that Section 1060(a)(1) of the Lanham Act, which restricts the assignment of intent-to-use applications before an amendment to allege use is filed, was not violated because UNIP did not assign its pending applications but rather received an assignment of preexisting common law rights to an already-used mark.
The Federal Circuit also rejected Game Plan’s argument that UNIP’s acquisition of common law rights during the opposition proceeding constituted an impermissible substantive amendment to its applications under 37 C.F.R. § 2.133(a). The court explained that this regulation governs amendments to pending applications, not independent transfers of common law rights, and that UNIP’s common law rights would establish priority regardless of the regulation’s constraints.
Additionally, the Federal Circuit found no error in the TTAB’s evidentiary rulings, noting that Game Plan was properly advised of procedural requirements and that documents not reintroduced during the testimony period were correctly excluded.
Game Plan’s petition for certiorari raised two principal questions: first, whether the Federal Circuit erred in holding that common law trademark rights can supersede a federally registered mark; and second, whether acquiring common law rights after an inter partes proceeding has commenced can defeat a federally registered mark in cancellation proceedings.
Game Plan argued that the Federal Circuit’s ruling conflicted with Section 1115(b) of the Lanham Act, which states that an incontestable registration constitutes conclusive evidence of exclusive rights. It also cited Section 1057(c), which grants nationwide priority to the registrant as of the filing date against all except prior users. Game Plan further referenced Seventh Circuit precedent holding that federal registration freezes territorial rights as of the registration date, preventing common law rights acquired thereafter from defeating the registered mark outside the prior user’s territory.
Regarding the second question, Game Plan contended that UNIP’s mid-proceeding acquisition of common law rights was effectively an impermissible substantive amendment under 37 C.F.R. § 2.133(a), transforming UNIP’s legal position without consent or Board approval. Game Plan asserted that the Federal Circuit’s decision lacked precedent and undermined regulatory safeguards against such changes during opposition proceedings.
With the Supreme Court’s denial of certiorari, the Federal Circuit’s ruling and the TTAB’s cancellation of Game Plan’s registration stand as binding precedent.
Supreme Court Declines Review in Dispute Over Common Law Trademark Priority The U.S. Supreme Court denied certiorari in Game Plan, Inc. v. Uninterrupted IP, LLC, leaving intact a Federal Circuit decision that upheld the Trademark Trial and Appeal Board’s cancellation of Game Plan’s federal trad... Read the full IIPLA article: https://iipla.org/news/supreme-court-declines-review-in-dispute-over-common-law-trademark-priority