Patent infringement disputes frequently give rise to complex jurisdictional conflicts, particularly when parallel litigation unfolds across multiple countries. While much recent attention has focused on standard essential patents, even straightforward infringement claims can provoke jurisdictional challenges. In a notable development, the U.S. District Court for the Western District of Texas issued an anti-suit injunction barring Chinese entities from continuing litigation in China related to a U.S. patent, asserting that only U.S. federal courts have authority to adjudicate rights under U.S. patents.
The case involves Telebrands, a New Jersey corporation holding a U.S. patent on a specific expandable garden hose. After discovering that several Chinese companies were selling allegedly infringing garden hoses on Amazon, Telebrands utilized Amazon’s internal “Patent Evaluation Express” complaint mechanism to have those products removed from the platform.
In response, some of these Chinese entities initiated declaratory judgment actions in U.S. courts, seeking declarations of non-infringement. One such case was abandoned, and another, filed by an affiliated entity, was dismissed for lack of standing.
Subsequently, in March 2025, certain Chinese defendants filed suit against Telebrands in the Yangjiang Intermediate People’s Court in Guangdong Province, China. They contended their products did not infringe Telebrands’ U.S. patent and alleged that Telebrands’ efforts to delist their products from Amazon constituted unfair competition. Their claims sought damages and an injunction preventing Telebrands from filing further complaints with Amazon.
Because the unfair competition claims depended on a finding of non-infringement, adjudicating those claims would require the Chinese court to resolve the question of infringement under U.S. patent law. Telebrands challenged the Chinese court’s jurisdiction, arguing that U.S. courts exclusively possess authority to determine rights under U.S. patents. The Chinese court rejected this jurisdictional objection, a ruling upheld on appeal.
In response, Telebrands filed a patent infringement suit in the Western District of Texas and sought an anti-suit injunction to (1) halt the ongoing Chinese litigation, (2) prevent any adjudication of U.S. patent rights in China, and (3) bar the defendants from seeking an anti-anti-suit injunction in China.
On June 9, 2026, the court held an ex parte hearing and issued a temporary restraining order. Following additional briefing, on June 22, 2026, the court granted the anti-suit injunction, limiting its scope to proceedings concerning the specific U.S. patent at issue.
Judge Xavier Rodriguez, in the June 22 order, reiterated findings from the June 9 TRO. He acknowledged that federal courts have authority to enjoin foreign proceedings intended to divest U.S. courts of jurisdiction in cases properly before them, a category known as “interdictory” proceedings. However, at this stage, the Chinese litigation did not appear to interfere directly with the U.S. case, as the Chinese defendants had not sought to enjoin Telebrands from pursuing its U.S. litigation but rather aimed to block Telebrands’ use of Amazon’s complaint mechanism.
The judge’s principal concern centered on the adjudication of U.S. patent law by a foreign court, which he found would frustrate U.S. policy. Citing BMW v. Onesta, a Western District of Texas decision earlier in 2026 involving German litigation over a U.S. patent, Judge Rodriguez emphasized that foreign courts resolving U.S. patent infringement claims undermine the United States’ interest in adjudicating its own patents and protecting litigants’ jury rights.
While framed as a public policy rationale, the ruling effectively asserts that U.S. federal courts hold exclusive jurisdiction over U.S. patent rights. Judge Rodriguez characterized the foreign proceedings as attempts to obtain “illegitimate” determinations of U.S. patent law. This position contrasts with the statutory language of 28 U.S.C. § 1338(a), which grants exclusive jurisdiction to federal courts over patent cases but does not explicitly address foreign court jurisdiction.
The court concluded that the anti-suit injunction serves the public interest by preserving Telebrands’ U.S. patent rights and preventing foreign courts from issuing determinations that could harm those rights. Notably, the order did not engage in detailed analysis of international comity or the potential impact on the Chinese defendants’ unfair competition claims, considerations typically required under the Fifth Circuit’s anti-suit injunction framework.
This case highlights challenging issues in cross-border patent enforcement. If U.S. federal courts indeed possess exclusive jurisdiction over U.S. patents, foreign court rulings on such patents may lack recognition and enforcement in the United States. This raises the question of whether existing mechanisms for recognition and enforcement sufficiently protect U.S. patent holders or whether preemptive measures like anti-suit injunctions are warranted to prevent foreign proceedings from progressing.
Western District of Texas Issues Anti-Suit Injunction Affirming U.S. Courts’ Exclusive Jurisdiction Over U.S. Patent Rights In a recent ruling, the U.S. District Court for the Western District of Texas granted an anti-suit injunction preventing Chinese entities from pursuing parallel litigation in China concerning alleged infringement of a U... Read the full IIPLA article: https://iipla.org/news/western-district-of-texas-issues-anti-suit-injunction-affirming-u-s-courts-exclusive-jurisdiction-over-u-s-patent-rights