Intellectual property warranty and indemnity clauses serve as critical legal mechanisms for buyers to manage risks related to IP litigation and associated financial liabilities arising from products supplied by sellers. In Taiwan, courts generally interpret these clauses in a manner favorable to buyers, particularly when both parties are commercial entities. A recurring negotiation issue is whether a seller’s indemnity obligation should hinge on "actual infringement" of the supplied products or if an "asserted infringement" claim suffices to trigger indemnity. Typically, parties resolve this through explicit contract language or fail to reach agreement, leaving the question rarely litigated in Taiwan’s courts.
However, a notable exception emerged in April 2020 when a three-judge panel of Taiwan’s Intellectual Property Court issued a second-instance ruling in Unity Opto Technology, Ltd. v. TongFang Semiconductor (HK) Co., Ltd. (Case No. 108 Min Zhuan Shang 30). The court sided with the buyer, Unity Opto, clarifying that indemnity obligations arise upon asserted infringement claims, not solely upon proof of actual infringement.
The dispute centered on an indemnity letter drafted by Unity Opto in English and signed by TongFang without revisions. The letter contained two key provisions: first, a warranty by TongFang that its chip products did not infringe any third-party intellectual property rights, including patents, copyrights, trade secrets, industrial designs, know-how, or trademarks; second, an indemnity clause obligating TongFang to defend, indemnify, and hold Unity Opto harmless against any asserted claims, suits, injunctions, demands, actions, expenses, losses, or damages arising from breach of the warranty.
In 2015, TongFang’s chips incorporated in Unity Opto’s LED products sold in the United States were accused of infringing four patents in an International Trade Commission Section 337 investigation and a related lawsuit filed by Cree Inc., the patent holder. Unity Opto promptly notified TongFang and requested a joint defense agreement, which TongFang declined to sign, failing to fulfill its indemnity obligations or provide defense assistance.
Unity Opto ultimately settled with Cree Inc. in late 2016, incurring over US$1 million in attorney and expert witness fees. TongFang refused to reimburse these costs, prompting Unity Opto to initiate litigation in Taiwan, likely based on a jurisdiction clause in the indemnity letter or supply agreement.
TongFang argued that the indemnity clause’s second paragraph only applied if the warranty in the first paragraph was actually breached—that is, if the products were proven to infringe. Since the US proceedings were settled without a finding of infringement, and Unity Opto denied infringement throughout, TongFang contended no indemnity obligation arose.
The IP Court rejected this narrow, textual interpretation. It awarded Unity Opto the full amount of claimed attorney and expert fees, reasoning that IP litigation is costly and complex, often requiring lengthy proceedings before a final infringement determination. However, third-party claims and enforcement actions begin upon assertion of infringement, including demands, injunctions, and lawsuits, which immediately impact the accused party’s business and legal position.
The court emphasized that if indemnity obligations only arose after actual infringement was established, it would render the broad scope of the indemnity clause—including defense obligations against asserted claims—unreasonable and ineffective. This interpretation conflicted with the plain language and commercial purpose of the indemnity letter.
Further, the court noted that TongFang signed the indemnity letter without objection and that there was no significant disparity in bargaining power. Given TongFang’s superior technical knowledge of the products, it was reasonable to require it to provide technical materials and defense assistance to Unity Opto.
The court also highlighted the unfairness and risk to purchasers if indemnity were limited to actual infringement findings. Under TongFang’s theory, purchasers would bear defense costs themselves, unable to recover expenses even if ultimately successful, and might be incentivized to ignore infringement claims, undermining commercial fairness.
This decision illustrates the IP Court’s willingness to apply teleological analysis and reductio ad absurdum reasoning to interpret ambiguous contractual provisions in a manner consistent with commercial realities and fairness. Whether TongFang has appealed to Taiwan’s Supreme Court remains unknown, but this ruling is poised to influence IP indemnity practices and contract negotiations in Taiwan’s supply chains.
Legal practitioners and businesses are advised to carefully draft IP warranty and indemnity clauses with clear language addressing the triggering events and scope of indemnity to avoid costly disputes. The Unity Opto case serves as a cautionary precedent underscoring the buyer-friendly stance of Taiwan’s IP courts in indemnity matters.
This article provides a general overview and should not substitute for specialized legal advice tailored to specific circumstances.
Taiwan IP Court Rules Indemnity Triggered by Asserted, Not Just Actual, Infringement in Supply Chain Dispute Taiwan’s IP Court has issued a pivotal ruling addressing whether IP indemnity obligations require proof of actual infringement or can be triggered by asserted infringement claims. In Unity Opto Technology Ltd. v. TongFa... Read the full IIPLA article: https://iipla.org/news/taiwan-ip-court-rules-indemnity-triggered-by-asserted-not-just-actual-infringement-in-supply-chain-dispute